Understanding the Volatility of Closer Position in Fantasy Baseball
In the ever-evolving landscape of fantasy baseball, the closer position stands out as one of the most unpredictable elements on a roster. While elite pitchers and power hitters tend to deliver consistent yearly performance, the ninth-inning specialists often leave managers grappling with uncertainty.
The Nature of Closer Volatility
The allure of securing a "locked-in" 40-save closer may tempt drafters during 2026, but the reality is stark. Statistical history shows that the majority of MLB saves are not recorded by the pitchers designated as primary closers at the start of the season. Research indicates that over half of MLB saves are converted by pitchers other than the initial closer.
Yearly Trends in Closer Performance
The trend remains unsettling: in 2025, about 50% of the top 20 closers based on ADP (average draft position) fell short of their expected value. Factors such as:
- Injuries
- Poor performance
- Midseason trades
- A shift towards bullpen committees rather than singular closers
These elements combine to create a challenging environment for fantasy managers.
The Risks of Early Investment in Closers
Investing a high draft pick in a closer, like Mason Miller or Edwin Díaz, can appear attractive but comes with significant opportunity costs. In the previous season, top draft picks like Devin Williams, who was projected as a top-two closer, could only muster 18 saves before losing his closing role. Similarly, other renowned closers faced challenges, impacting their fantasy value.
The Data Speaks
Approximately 75% of saves come from the top 360 players based on ADP, while the remaining 25% can be found on the waiver wire. This indicates that many successful strategies involve waiting for saves later in your draft.
Late-Round Closer Value
A noteworthy example from 2025 is veteran Aroldis Chapman, who, after a low initial draft cost, finished the season with 32 saves and a remarkable 1.17 ERA. Similar opportunities may emerge for 2026 with pitchers like:
- Robert Garcia (Texas Rangers)
- Riley O’Brien (St. Louis Cardinals)
- Abner Uribe (Milwaukee Brewers)
These players may yield excellent returns for those opting to wait for saves during drafts.
Exploring Waiver Wire Options
Consider adding depth with potential waiver wire pickups such as Bryan Abreu from Houston. His teammate, Josh Hader, faces injury concerns, which could elevate Abreu’s value in 2026.
Smart Drafting Strategies
As you prepare for your upcoming drafts:
- Prioritize skills over the title: Look for pitchers with elite strikeout rates (35%+). Their effectiveness can add value even if they don’t land consistent save opportunities.
- Secure a mid-tier reliable arm: Rather than committing to a high-ranking closer, balance your team by investing in strong hitters or other positions.
Conclusion
In conclusion, navigating the closer position in fantasy baseball requires a strategic approach. Recognizing the potential for volatility and capitalizing on emerging talent can significantly influence your league’s outcomes.
For more insights into fantasy baseball strategies, keep exploring resources that provide in-depth analysis and tips. Engaging with the right content can elevate your fantasy baseball experience and keep you ahead of the competition.
Learn more about managing your fantasy baseball roster effectively.
