Celebrating 60 Years of Super Bowl Moments: The Top 10 Plays in Super Bowl History
As Super Bowl Sunday approaches, we celebrate not only the 60th anniversary of the Super Bowl but also the remarkable legacy of thrilling moments that have defined this iconic event. One such moment occurred during Super Bowl XLIX, where the New England Patriots and Seattle Seahawks clashed in a nail-biting finish. The game featured Malcolm Butler’s game-changing interception of Russell Wilson, marking one of the greatest defensive plays in history.
To commemorate this anniversary, we’ve gathered eight football writers’ insights to rank the top 10 plays in Super Bowl history. Let’s explore these unforgettable moments and see how they have shaped the Super Bowl narrative over the years.
The Greatest Plays in Super Bowl History
1. David Tyree’s Helmet Catch (77 points)
The iconic Helmet Catch during Super Bowl XLII remains the pinnacle of Super Bowl plays. Giants quarterback Eli Manning eluded multiple defenders to throw a 32-yard pass to David Tyree, who caught the ball against his helmet while being tackled. This improbable play sealed an upset against the previously undefeated Patriots.
2. Malcolm Butler’s Game-Saving Interception (70 points)
In one of the most suspenseful moments in Super Bowl history, Malcolm Butler intercepted a pass intended for Ricardo Lockette in the end zone, preserving the Patriots’ victory and cementing his place in history.
3. Santonio Holmes’ Toe-Tapping Touchdown (51 points)
Santonio Holmes’ breathtaking catch in the corner of the end zone during Super Bowl XLIII secured a dramatic win for the Pittsburgh Steelers against the Arizona Cardinals, showcasing both skill and precision.
4. Mike Jones’ Final-Play Tackle (43 points)
The decisive moment of Super Bowl XXXIV came when Mike Jones tackled Kevin Dyson just one yard short of a touchdown, ensuring a victory for the St. Louis Rams over the Tennessee Titans.
5. James Harrison’s 100-Yard Pick Six (31 points)
James Harrison’s stunning interception and subsequent 100-yard touchdown return underscored the defensive prowess of the Pittsburgh Steelers in Super Bowl XLIII, giving them a critical momentum shift in the game.
6. The Philly Special (24 points)
This innovative trick play, in which Eagles quarterback Nick Foles caught a touchdown pass from tight end Trey Burton, helped propel Philadelphia to its first Super Bowl victory in 2018, marking a new era in play-calling.
6. Julian Edelman’s Juggling Catch (24 points)
Edelman’s remarkable catch against the Atlanta Falcons in Super Bowl LI stands out for its sheer audacity and showcased his tenacity, helping to ignite the Patriots’ historic comeback.
8. Joe Montana’s Touchdown Pass to John Taylor (17 points)
In Super Bowl XXIII, Joe Montana connected with John Taylor for the game-winning touchdown, securing a victory for the San Francisco 49ers and further solidifying Montana’s legacy as one of the greatest quarterbacks.
9. John Elway’s Helicopter Dive (16 points)
In Super Bowl XXXII, John Elway’s remarkable dive for a first down exemplified his determination and grit, contributing to the Denver Broncos’ victory over the Green Bay Packers.
10. Marcus Allen’s Reverse-Field 74-Yard TD Run (14 points)
In a display of incredible athleticism, Marcus Allen evaded defenders on a breathtaking run during Super Bowl XVIII, showcasing both skill and strategic brilliance.
Notable Mentions
Along with the top 10 plays, several other memorable moments received votes, including:
- Lynn Swann’s catch over Mark Washington
- Adam Vinatieri’s game-winning field goal
- John Riggins’ iconic run
- The Saints’ bold onside kick to begin the second half in Super Bowl XLIV
Conclusion: The Legacy of Super Bowl Plays
As we prepare to witness another Super Bowl, these legendary plays remind us of the magic, suspense, and drama that define this championship game. Whether through miraculous catches or pivotal tackles, each moment captures the essence of football’s biggest stage. Which moments will join this esteemed list in the years to come?
For more insights and game analysis, check out articles on ESPN and NFL Network. As we celebrate this rich history, we look forward to witnessing new legends emerge in the future.
