Zohran Mamdani’s Mayoral Campaign Faces Setback with Satmar Community Division

New York City’s mayoral race heats up as Democratic Socialist candidate Zohran Mamdani enters the final stretch of the election. However, he finds himself without the crucial support of the influential Satmar Hasidic community following a political controversy over an unapproved endorsement.

Unauthorized Endorsement Leads to Community Backlash

Mamdani recently celebrated a meeting with Rabbi Moshe Indig, a leading political strategist for the Ahronim sect, who appeared to endorse his candidacy. Mamdani announced this on X (formerly Twitter), stating:

“I was honored to receive the endorsement of Rabbi Moshe Indig and Ahronim leaders in Williamsburg today, where we were joined by my friend @LincolnRestler. Together, we will fight the scourge of antisemitism and build a city that works for every New Yorker.”

Andrew Cuomo Steps In

Shortly after Mamdani’s announcement, his independent opponent, former Governor Andrew Cuomo, also claimed support from the Satmar Ahronim community. Cuomo shared on X:

“Sincerely honored by the endorsement of my good friends in the Satmar community.”

Three board members from the Ahronim faction confirmed Cuomo’s endorsement, stating that Mamdani’s progressive platform poses a threat to their community’s values as Torah Jews:

• They described the progressive agenda as a "crusading threat."
• Followers were urged to support Cuomo to counter the progressive movement.

Internal Discontent in the Satmar Community

According to Belaaz News, the Satmar board and congregation leaders were blindsided by the endorsement from Rabbi Indig, labeling it as “totally unauthorized.” The board, instructed by their Rebbe to remain neutral in the general election, opted to counter Rabbi Indig’s message by endorsing Cuomo instead.

Factional Dynamics within Satmar

The Satmar Hasidic dynasty is divided between two factions led by brothers Aharon Teitelbaum and Zalman Leib Teitelbaum:

• Rabbi Aharon Teitelbaum heads the Ahronim faction, primarily located in Kiryas Joel, NY, with a notable presence in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.
• Rabbi Zalman Leib Teitelbaum leads the more substantial Zaloynim faction in Williamsburg.

Both factions had previously supported Cuomo during their Democratic primary, but the Zaloynim faction has yet to issue an endorsement for the general election.

Rabbi Indig’s influence has been pivotal in previous high-profile endorsements for successful mayoral candidates like Bill de Blasio and Eric Adams, further complicating the endorsement situation.

Tension Over Political Alignment

This dispute highlights deeper rifts within the ultra-Orthodox Jewish community regarding support for Mamdani’s left-leaning, anti-Zionist views. The Satmar movement specifically does not recognize the legitimacy of the modern state of Israel, distinguishing itself from splinter groups like Neturei Karta, which are overtly anti-Zionist.

Criticism Across the Jewish Spectrum

Mamdani’s rhetoric has drawn criticism from leaders across the Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform Jewish movements. Some accuse him of:

• Mainstreaming antisemitism
• Undermining the longstanding ties between New York’s cultural and Jewish communities

Conclusion: A Divided Path Ahead

As the election approaches, the internal divisions within the Satmar community may alter the dynamics of New York City’s mayoral race considerably. Without the endorsement of such a crucial voting bloc, Mamdani faces challenges in rallying support against his competitors. The community’s unease with his platform on Israel and Zionism underscores the broader implications of this election for New York’s diverse neighborhoods.

For more insights on the New York City election race, visit City Limits or NYC Votes.