Fantasy Baseball: Outfielders to Avoid in 2025 Drafts

Gambling content for ages 21+. If you sign up through our links, the New York Post may receive an affiliate commission. For more information, visit our editorial standards page.

When preparing for your fantasy baseball draft, the focus often settles on which players to target. However, knowing whom to steer clear of can be just as crucial. In the outfield, distinguishing between sustainable performance and fleeting statistical flukes is key. Here are three veterans to avoid in 2025 drafts, particularly due to their current average draft positions (ADPs) that may attract unwarranted attention.

1. George Springer: Crossing the Age Cliff

Despite a remarkable 161 OPS+ and a .309 batting average last season, George Springer’s impressive 2025 stats may mask underlying concerns.

• Current Risks:
  • Age Factor: Emerging from an age-35 season, Springer’s peak performance raises questions about longevity.
  • Diminishing Skills: Analysis reveals he is heavily reliant on elite bat-to-ball skills. As his physical attributes fade, maintaining such impressive averages becomes increasingly unlikely.

Statistical history shows that targeting players with recent career highs at an advanced age rarely yields positive outcomes. Investing in Springer at his current draft position is a gamble fraught with risk.

2. Byron Buxton: A Statistical Gamble

Byron Buxton’s season in 2025 was a statistical masterpiece, featuring 35 home runs and a flawless 24-for-24 on stolen base attempts. However, managing to stay healthy for 126 games is an outlier in his career.

• Health History: Buxton’s injury-prone nature makes him a risky proposition.
• High Ceiling, Low Floor: His perfect stealing success is unsustainable, indicating potential regression.

As his ADP climbs into the top 40, drafting Buxton means banking on an unrealistic level of health—something he has achieved only twice in his decade-long career.

3. Christian Yelich: The Statistical Correction

Christian Yelich managed to play 150 games last season, which is encouraging, but the underlying stats tell a different story.

• Concerning Trends:
  • Spike in Strikeouts: His strikeout rate has surged toward 25 percent.
  • Declining Exit Velocity: Both hard-hit rates and average exit velocity are at their lowest since his MVP days.

Yelich’s increased reliance on batting average on balls in play (BABIP) and a ground-ball-heavy approach raises alarms. As his speed wanes and defenses adjust, expect fewer hits and reduced power output.

Conclusion: Prioritize Value Over Brand Names

As you consider your fantasy outfield strategy, the key takeaway is to prioritize younger players with higher ceilings over established veterans with shaky floors.

Quick Recap of Players to Avoid

• George Springer: Age and physical decline are concerns.
• Byron Buxton: Injury history casts doubt on sustainability.
• Christian Yelich: Underlying stats suggest an impending decline.

By steering clear of these players at their current ADPs, you open opportunities to draft younger, high-upside talents who have their prime years ahead.

Incorporating these insights into your draft strategy can significantly enhance your roster’s strength as you head into the new season.

For further insights on MLB betting, visit our guide on fantasy baseball. Enjoy drafting and may your fantasy season be a successful one!